This article, based on interviews with principals from schools undergoing reform interventions under state takeover, offers these principals’ perspectives on the first school year under the new ‘multiple provider model.’ RFA researchers interviewed twenty principals from schools managed either by external EMOs or the District’s Office of Restructured Schools (ORS), as well as representatives from the District and the EMOs. A primary finding was that communications and decision-making became both complicated and confusing. Many principals felt like they were ‘serving two masters,’ which resulted in both duplication of tasks and inconsistent or missing information. Developing a clear system for coordinating communication among the many players in this complex management model remains a major challenge for the District. Principals held varying views, ranging from positive through mixed to negative, on changes brought by new management in curriculum, professional development, assessment, and student support. Most reported benefiting from new instructional materials or technology. According to principals of schools under private EMOs, some benefited from reductions in class size, but suffered from staffing cuts which eliminated NTAs (non-teaching assistants), assistant principals, intern teachers, and librarians. The article reports that RFA will continue its research with in-depth case studies of a smaller number of schools to follow the course of reforms over the next school year.
Supports and Challenges in the Multiple Provider Model: Principals Offer Mixed Perspectives on First Year of Takeover
Date: October 2006
Related Publications
Publication
Students Experiencing Homelessness in Pennsylvania: A 2024 Update
David Lapp, Anna Shaw-Amoah
Publication
The When and How of Keystone Exams in the School District of Philadelphia
Molly Pileggi, Sean Vannata, Alyn Turner
Publication
Understanding Increases in Head Start Teacher Turnover During COVID-19
Kendall LaParo, Anna Shaw-Amoah
Publication
Examining the Effectiveness of Race-Specific Funding Strategies in Higher Education
Kri Burkander, Shafiqua Little, Mycaeri Atkinson
Publication
“For the Good of the City” An Early Evaluation of the Catto Scholarship
Kri Burkander, Karin Gegenheimer, Alita Robinson
Publication
Revisiting Research on School Closings: Key Learnings for District and Community Leaders
Mary Eddins, Maja Pehrson, Kevin Burgess
Publication
Responding, Reimagining, Realizing: Out-of-School Coordination in a New Era
Tracey A. Hartmann, Wendy McClanahan, Mark Duffy, Leana Cabral, Carolyn Barnes, Ph.D, Brian Christens, Ph.D
Publication
Personalized, Competency-Based Learning in Arizona: A Case Study of Implementation in Yuma Union High School District
Kevin Burgess, Julia Ransom, Mark Duffy
Publication
Personalized, Competency-Based Learning in Arizona: A Case Study of Implementation in an Elementary School in Santa Cruz Valley Unified School District 35
Julia Ransom, Kevin Burgess, Mark Duffy
Publication
Personalized, Competency-Based Learning in Arizona: A Preliminary Report on Implementation and Student Outcomes
Karin Gegenheimer, Dae Y. Kim, Mark Duffy
Publication
Examining the Impact, Implementation, and Cost Effectiveness of Completion Coaching in a Statewide College Promise Program
Dae Y. Kim, Karin Gegenheimer
Publication
Children’s Literacy Initiative’s Blueprint for Early Learning: Evaluation Report
Alyn Turner, Jill Pierce, Kendall LaParo